7 Critical Insights on Roof Age and Insurance: What Homeowners Must Know


In the world of homeownership, understanding the nuances of property insurance is crucial, especially when it comes to the roof over your head. Roofs, arguably the most protective element of a home, present a complex challenge when dealing with insurance carriers. This article delves deep into the issues homeowners face with roofs and insurance carriers, from age limitations and ariel inspections to the intricacies of coverage options.

The Age Factor: Roofs Older Than 15 Years

Challenges with Aging Roofs

Roofs older than 15 years are often seen as liabilities by insurance companies. The wear and tear, potential for leaks, and overall degradation can significantly increase the risk of claims, prompting insurers to either deny coverage or increase premiums.

Insurance Carrier’s Perspective

For insurance carriers, the decision to not write policies for roofs over 15 years old stems from a risk assessment standpoint. Aging roofs are more susceptible to damage, leading to a higher likelihood of claims.

Ariel Inspections and Their Impact

The Process of Ariel Inspections

Ariel inspections have become a standard procedure for many insurance companies. Using drones or satellite imagery, insurers can assess a roof’s condition without a physical inspection.

Consequences of Roof Staining

Roof staining, visible from aerial images, can indicate potential issues such as moss growth or water damage. Such findings can lead insurers to decline coverage or alter the terms unfavorably for homeowners.

Actual Cash Value vs. Replacement Coverage

Understanding Actual Cash Value

Actual Cash Value (ACV) coverage considers the depreciation of your roof. In the event of damage, ACV policies pay out the replacement cost minus depreciation and deductible, often resulting in lower payouts.

The Downside of Actual Cash Value Coverage

Opting for ACV coverage can be financially burdensome in the long run, especially for owners of older roofs. The reduced payout may not cover the full cost of repairs or replacement, leaving homeowners to cover the difference.

The Dilemma of Old Roofs

Risks Associated with Old Roofs

Older roofs pose significant risks, from leaks to structural damage. These issues can not only lead to expensive repairs but also affect the overall safety and integrity of the home.

Insurance Implications

Insurance companies scrutinize older roofs closely, often requiring additional inspections or limiting coverage options. Homeowners may find themselves with higher premiums or reduced coverage.

The Threat Posed by Trees

Ariel Views on Tree Limbs Over Homes

Tree limbs hanging over homes are red flags for insurance carriers. The potential for damage from falling branches or exacerbated wear on roofs leads to strict policy conditions or outright denial of coverage.

The Insurance Perspective on Tree Claims

Tree-related claims have surged, leading insurers to adopt more stringent policies. Homeowners may face higher deductibles or specific exclusions for tree-related damage.

The Increasing Deductibles for Wind and Hail Damage

The Trend Towards Higher Deductibles

In response to the rising number of claims from wind and hail, insurance companies are moving towards higher deductibles. This shift aims to mitigate financial losses for insurers and encourage homeowners to take preventative measures.

The Reasoning Behind the Increase

The increase in deductibles for wind and hail damage is a direct result of the financial strain caused by frequent claims. By imposing higher deductibles, insurers can ensure that homeowners share a greater part of the risk.

Property Inspection and Roof Replacement

The Role of Property Inspections

Property inspections play a pivotal role in determining the condition of a roof and its eligibility for coverage. Inspectors look for signs of wear, damage, and potential risks that could lead to claims.

The Urgency of Roof Replacement

For homes with aging or damaged roofs, replacement is often not just recommended but required. Insurance companies may demand roof replacement as a condition for coverage, highlighting the importance of maintaining a home’s roof in top condition.

Insurance Coverage Adjustments

From Replacement Cost to Actual Cash Value

Insurance companies may adjust coverage from replacement cost to actual cash value after inspections reveal the need for roof replacement. This change significantly affects the coverage level and potential payout in case of damage.

The Impact of Coverage Reduction

Reductions in coverage can leave homeowners vulnerable, facing higher out-of-pocket costs for roof repairs or replacement. Understanding the terms and conditions of your policy is essential to navigate these situations.

Navigating Insurance with Aging Roofs and Tree Risks

Strategies for Homeowners

Homeowners can take several steps to navigate the challenges presented by aging roofs and tree risks. Regular maintenance, timely replacements, and clear communication with insurance carriers can help secure better coverage terms.

How to Secure Adequate Coverage

Securing adequate coverage may involve shopping around for insurance providers, negotiating terms, or even making home improvements to meet insurer requirements. Being proactive about roof maintenance and tree management can also make a significant difference.

Future Trends in Home Insurance

Predictions for Roof and Tree Claim Policies

As the industry adapts to changing risks, we may see more insurance companies adjusting their policies regarding roofs and trees. Higher deductibles, stricter coverage criteria, and increased use of technology for inspections are likely trends.

How Homeowners Can Prepare

To stay ahead, homeowners should remain informed about potential changes in the insurance landscape. Investing in home improvements, maintaining a good relationship with insurers, and understanding policy details are key strategies.


The relationship between roofs, trees, and insurance carriers is complex, with many factors influencing coverage decisions and policy terms. By staying informed and proactive, homeowners can navigate these challenges effectively, securing the coverage they need to protect their homes.


  • What should I do if my insurance company requires a roof replacement for coverage?
  • How can I minimize the impact of tree risks on my insurance policy?
  • What are the benefits and drawbacks of Actual Cash Value coverage?
  • How do deductibles for wind and hail damage affect homeowners?
  • Can regular maintenance impact my insurance coverage options?
  • What steps should I take if my insurance coverage is reduced after an inspection?

Would You Like Us To Review Your Policies?

Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at McGroarty & Bradburn Insurance is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Call Email Claims Payments